In partnership with

Why Most People Fail at Workplace Persuasion

You don't have the title. You don't control the budget. You can't make anyone do anything.

And yet some people, with the same limitations, seem to get yes after yes.

The difference isn't charisma. It's not luck. It's a system most people never learn.

Here's the framework I've used to get buy-in from C-suites, government committees, and clients who started the conversation with "no."

The Influence System: 4 Steps to Getting Yes

Step 1: Lower the Threat

Before you pitch anything, reduce the other person's defensive response. Chris Voss calls this "tactical empathy," but the principle is simpler: acknowledge their reality before asking them to enter yours.

Start with what they're worried about. Name it before they have to.

"I know the timing on this is tight and you've got three other priorities competing for attention..."

You've now positioned yourself as someone who gets it, not someone adding to their problems.

Step 2: Align With Identity

People say yes to things that match how they see themselves. Your job is to frame your ask as something "a person like them" would naturally do.

For a data-driven executive: "Given your track record of making evidence-based calls..."

For a risk-averse manager: "Since protecting the team is your priority..."

You're not manipulating. You're helping them see that saying yes is consistent with who they already are.

Step 3: Shrink the Ask

Big asks trigger big resistance. The solution isn't to ask for less, but to make the first step smaller.

Instead of "approve this project," try "give me 15 minutes to show you the pilot results."

Instead of "hire me," try "let me handle one small piece and prove the concept."

Small yeses create momentum. Momentum creates big yeses.

Step 4: Create Safe Exits

People resist commitment when they feel trapped. Give them an out, and paradoxically, they become more likely to stay.

"If this doesn't hit the benchmarks in 30 days, we kill it. No questions."

The safety net makes the jump feel survivable.

Start your year with clarity

Written by Shane Parrish and reMarkable, this workbook helps you reflect without complexity or stress. It guides you through the past year with intention, so insights emerge naturally.


This isn’t about setting more goals. It’s about understanding what matters, clearly and calmly.


A simple reset for January. A thoughtful way to review your year.

The Psychology Behind the System

This framework works because it addresses the three emotional blockers I mentioned yesterday: threat response, effort perception, and identity mismatch.

Robert Cialdini's research on pre-suasion confirms it: what you do before making a request matters more than the request itself. The setup determines the outcome.

Corporate application: Use this before asking for promotions, project approvals, budget increases, or cross-functional support. Lower threat first, align with their identity, shrink the initial commitment, provide a safe exit.

Creator application: Use this on sales calls, partnership pitches, and client negotiations. The prospect who feels understood and un-pressured is the prospect who buys.

Leadership Can’t Be Automated

AI can help you move faster, but real leadership still requires human judgment.

The free resource 5 Traits AI Can’t Replace explains the traits leaders must protect in an AI-driven world and why BELAY Executive Assistants are built to support them.

The Influence System Checklist

Before your next important ask, run through this:

  • Have I acknowledged their current reality/concerns?

  • Have I framed this as consistent with their identity?

  • Is my first ask small enough to feel easy?

  • Have I provided a clear exit if it doesn't work?

Print this. Use it before every pitch, proposal, and presentation.

Running a newsletter or community? Beehiiv makes the tech invisible so you can focus on the influence. Reply with subject line 'SETUP HELP' using the email you signed up with, and I'll share exactly how I set mine up.

Smarter CX insights for investors and founders

Join The Gladly Brief for insights on how AI, satisfaction, and loyalty intersect to shape modern business outcomes. Subscribe now to see how Gladly is redefining customer experience as an engine of growth—not a cost center.

Go Deeper: The Advanced Influence Tactics

The following is for Pro members only.

logo

Subscribe to PRO Member to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of PRO Member to get access to the transformational content on this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

A subscription gets you:

  • 🔒 Premium-only guides on mindset, emotional control, conflict, and influence
  • 🎁 Downloads & tactical playbooks (for real-world use, not fluff)

Reply

or to participate

Keep Reading

No posts found