Why Your Testimonials Are Weak

In partnership with

You have testimonials.

They're on your website. Maybe in your email signature. Possibly scattered across LinkedIn.

But here's the uncomfortable truth: they're doing almost nothing for your credibility.

Here's what most entrepreneurs get when they ask for testimonials:

"Great to work with! Highly professional. Would recommend."

Sounds nice, right?

Completely useless.

Generic testimonials are credibility theater. They look like social proof, but they don't actually prove anything. Anyone could say that about anyone. There's no specificity. No transformation. No reason for a prospect to think "Oh, THIS person can help ME."

You're collecting testimonials wrong. And it's costing you clients.

The Three Mistakes That Kill Testimonial Value

Here's what I figured out after watching entrepreneurs struggle with this.

Mistake 1: You're asking at the wrong time

Most people wait until a project is "done" to ask for testimonials. By then, the emotional high of the transformation has faded. Your client is thinking about their next problem, not the one you just solved.

The best testimonials come from peak satisfaction moments. Right after a major win. Right after they say something like "This is exactly what I needed." Right after they refer someone to you unprompted.

That's when emotion is high. That's when they remember the before-state pain clearly. That's when they'll give you gold instead of generic praise.

Mistake 2: You're making it too hard

"Can you write me a testimonial?" puts all the work on them.

They have to remember what you did. Figure out what to say. Worry if it's good enough. Most people freeze. They want to help, but the blank page is intimidating.

So they either don't do it, or they write something safe and generic just to get it done.

You need to make saying yes easier than saying no.

Mistake 3: You're accepting weak testimonials

Someone sends you: "Really enjoyed working together. Great communicator. Delivered on time."

You think: "Well, it's something. Better than nothing."

Wrong.

A weak testimonial is worse than no testimonial. It signals to prospects that even your happy clients can't think of anything specific to praise. It makes you look forgettable.

You need a system to guide clients toward specific, transformation-focused testimonials. Not by being pushy, but by asking the right questions that make specificity easy.

Ad break: Please support the newsletter, by clicking the links of today’s two amazing sponsors Author Inc. and Morning Brew.

After that we return to the goodies!!

Will A Book Grow Your Business?

No one buys a beach house from selling a book. They buy the beach house from the opportunities the book gets them.

Author.Inc helps experts, executives, and entrepreneurs turn expertise into world‑class books that build revenue, reputation, and reach. 

Their team—behind projects with Tim Ferriss and Codie Sanchez—cuts through uncertainty to show whether your book can realistically hit those targets. 

Schedule a complimentary 15‑minute call with Author.Inc’s co‑founder to quantify potential ROI from your offers, speaking engagements, royalties, and more. 

This isn’t writing advice. It’s a strategic consultation to decide whether now is the right time to put pen to paper. 

If it’s a go, they’ll show you how to write and publish it at a world-class level. If it’s a wait, you just avoided wasting time and money.

Get Your Free Book ROI Assessment.

An espresso shot for your brain

The problem with most business news? It’s too long, too boring, and way too complicated.

Morning Brew fixes all three. In five minutes or less, you’ll catch up on the business, finance, and tech stories that actually matter—written with clarity and just enough humor to keep things interesting.

It’s quick. It’s free. And it’s how over 4 million professionals start their day. Signing up takes less than 15 seconds—and if you’d rather stick with dense, jargon-packed business news, you can always unsubscribe.

Check it out

Thank you all who clicked the links ♥️

What Strong Testimonials Actually Look Like

Here's the difference.

Weak testimonial: "John helped us with our marketing strategy. He's very knowledgeable and easy to work with. Would definitely recommend."

What does this tell a prospect? Nothing. What did John actually do? What changed? Why would I hire him?

Strong testimonial: "Before working with John, we were spending $8K/month on ads with inconsistent results. He built us a content system that now generates 35 qualified leads per month organically. We cut our ad spend by 60% and our pipeline is fuller than it's ever been. If you're tired of burning money on ads that don't convert, talk to John."

See the difference?

Specific problem. Specific solution. Specific results. Clear transformation. The prospect reading this can immediately tell if they have the same problem and if John can solve it.

That's a testimonial that converts.

The 5-Minute System

Here's what changes everything.

Stop asking "Can you write me a testimonial?" and start using a three-part system that gets specific, powerful testimonials in under five minutes of client time.

The system has three components:

Component 1: Perfect Timing

Ask within 48 hours of a major win or peak satisfaction moment. Not at project completion. Not weeks later. Right when the emotional impact is fresh.

Keep a running list of "testimonial trigger moments" - times when asking feels natural and the client is most likely to say yes enthusiastically.

Component 2: The Request Script

Instead of asking them to write something from scratch, you offer to draft it based on your work together, then they can edit or approve.

This removes the blank page problem. It makes saying yes take 2 minutes instead of 20. And it ensures the testimonial includes the specifics that actually matter.

Component 3: The 3-Question Framework

When you draft testimonials (or guide clients who prefer to write their own), structure them around three questions:

1. What problem did you have before working with me?

2. What specific results did you achieve?

3. Who should work with me and why?

These three questions force specificity. They create the before-after transformation arc. They make the testimonial useful for prospects trying to decide if you can help them.

Every strong testimonial answers all three. Every weak testimonial misses at least one.

Your Saturday Action

Here's what you're getting today.

I've packaged this entire system into a 9-page PDF guide: "The 5-Minute Testimonial Collection System: Scripts, Timing & the 3-Question Framework."

Inside:

• The complete timing framework (when to ask = 80% of success)

• The exact request script I use (makes saying yes effortless)

• The 3-Question Framework breakdown (gets specific testimonials every time)

• What to do with weak testimonials (the upgrade script)

• 7-day action plan (collect 3 high-quality testimonials this week)

This guide is available for everyone on Etsy for $9 (Vat will be added on top for EU buyers). BUT I'm giving it to newsletter Founder and Pro subscribers for free as it is one of the perks being a Pro/Founder member.

Download from Etsy:

 (Free for Founder and Pro subscribers of this newsletter)

Use it this week. Follow the 7-day plan. Get 3 testimonials that actually build credibility instead of just taking up space on your website.

The difference between weak testimonials and strong testimonials is about five minutes of using the right system.

You already have happy clients. Now get testimonials that prove it.

Reinforce your learning by watching this video!

P.S. If you're not subscribed to PRO membership yet and want access to premium guides like this click the link below and join FREE 7-day trial available for the rest of the 2025.

I drop advanced implementation tools that would cost $7-25 elsewhere. Free for the paid subscribers.

Subscribe to PRO Member to read the rest.